是EnableDelayedExpansion还是呼叫集？

如何解决是EnableDelayedExpansion还是呼叫集？

在这样的代码中：

set /p "PROGNAME=enter the name of the prog: "
set /p "VERSION=enter the version of the prog: "
setlocal enabledelayedexpansion
if "%PROGNAME%"=="foo" (
    set "OPTIONS=(someParams)"
    set "PROGPATH=C:\MyPath\%PROGNAME%%OPTIONS%_%VERSION%.exe"
) else if "%PROGNAME%"=="bar" (
    set "OPTIONS=(otherParams)"
    set "PROGPATH=C:\MyPath\%PROGNAME%%OPTIONS%_%VERSION%.exe"
)
set "PROGDLL=!PROGPATH:%PROGNAME%=%PROGNAME%dll!"
endlocal

我了解到enabledelayedexpansion变量都需要PROGPATH，因为它与变量OPTIONS和PROGDLL处于同一循环中变量，因为替换。

但是，在这种特殊情况下，我不希望变量是局部的。就像，一点也不；即使在脚本结束后，我也想访问它们。因此无法使用enabledelayedexpansion。

然后我做了这样的事情：

set /p "PROGNAME=enter the name of the prog: "
set /p "VERSION=enter the version of the prog: "
if "%PROGNAME%"=="foo" (
    set "OPTIONS=(someParams)"
    call set "PROGPATH=C:\MyPath\%PROGNAME%%OPTIONS%_%VERSION%.exe"
    call set "PROGDLL=%%PROGPATH:foo=foodll%%"
) else if "%PROGNAME%"=="bar" (
    set "OPTIONS=(otherParams)"
    call set "PROGPATH=C:\MyPath\%PROGNAME%%%OPTIONS%%_%VERSION%.exe"
    call set "PROGDLL=%%PROGPATH:bar=bardll%%"
)

尽管这很好用，但我现在很迷失：如果只需要一个call set，enabledelayedexpansion的意义是什么？我的意思是，每次需要在循环中设置一些因变量时，我都会在脚本中使用enabledelayedexpansion，是否应该将所有变量替换为call set并删除enabledelayedexpansion？

一般来说，我想了解何时应该使用enabledelayedexpansion和何时应该使用call set。

（还有为什么将%%与call set一起使用？）

解决方法

好吧，您的代码实际上应该像这样：

rem // At this point,the default state should apply,hence no delayed expansion:
set /P "PROGNAME=enter the name of the prog: "
set /P "VERSION=enter the version of the prog: "
setlocal EnableDelayedExpansion
rem /* At this point,delayed expansion should be applied for all possible variables,rem    because otherwise,you may run into problems with exclamation marks: */
if "!PROGNAME!"=="foo" (
    set "OPTIONS=(someParams)"
    rem /* You need `!OPTIONS!` here,of course,since it is set in the same block;
    rem    but you should also use `!PROGNAME!` and `!VERSION!` herein: */
    set "PROGPATH=C:\MyPath\!PROGNAME!!OPTIONS!_!VERSION!.exe"
) else if "!PROGNAME!"=="bar" (
    set "OPTIONS=(otherParams)"
    set "PROGPATH=C:\MyPath\!PROGNAME!!OPTIONS!_!VERSION!.exe"
)
rem /* For the sub-string substitution,you should avoid immediate expansion,rem    because you may get in trouble with unbalanced quotes,if applicable;
rem    you could use a `for /F` loop to delay expansion of search/replace strings;
rem    as you can see,delayed expansion is used as much as possible,and
rem    the whole replacement expression is transferred to the `for` meta-variable: */
for /F "delims=" %%S in ("!PROGNAME!=!PROGNAME!dll") do set "PROGDLL=!PROGPATH:%%I!"
rem /* To avoid loss of set variables due to end of the environment localisation,rem    use another `for /F` loop; delayed expansion is used as much as possible,and
rem    the whole assignment expression is transferred to the `for` meta-variable: */
for /F "delims=" %%E in ("PROGPATH=!PROGPATH!") do endlocal & set "%%E"

请注意，设置的变量仅在运行批处理脚本的同一cmd.exe实例中可用。

---

如果您要使用call而不是延迟扩展，则代码应为：

rem // At this point,hence no delayed expansion:
set /P "PROGNAME=enter the name of the prog: "
set /P "VERSION=enter the version of the prog: "
setlocal EnableDelayedExpansion
if "%PROGNAME%"=="foo" (
    set "OPTIONS=(someParams)"
    rem // You need `call` here,since `OPTIONS` is set in the same block:
    call set "PROGPATH=C:\MyPath\%PROGNAME%%%OPTIONS%%_%VERSION%.exe"
    rem /* Here is an alternative way using `%%` for all variables,which may avoid
    rem    problems with unbalanced quotes,but you may get unwanted `^`-doubling: */
    rem call set "PROGPATH=C:\MyPath\%%PROGNAME%%%%OPTIONS%%_%%VERSION%%.exe"
) else if "!PROGNAME!"=="bar" (
    set "OPTIONS=(otherParams)"
    call set "PROGPATH=C:\MyPath\%PROGNAME%%%OPTIONS%%_%VERSION%.exe"
    rem call set "PROGPATH=C:\MyPath\%%PROGNAME%%%%OPTIONS%%_%%VERSION%%.exe"
)
rem // Of course you will need `call` for the sub-string substitution:
call set "PROGDLL=%%PROGPATH:%PROGNAME%=%PROGNAME%dll%%"

但是请注意，这种方法比较慢，并且插入符号^可能会不必要地加倍，您可能会遇到麻烦。此外，%%可能会引起for元变量的意外扩展，例如，当代码放置在%%P适用的部分内时，call set "PROGDLL=%%PROGPATH:…%%"将导致因为%%P部分已扩展。